Time to bring it home. Find zipForm®, transaction tools, and all the closing resources you'll need. Except for the champagne — that's on you.
Time to bring it home. Complete transactions and contracts electronically through zipForm®.
Realtor® Secure Transaction is your place to discover, access and master the essential tools for a modern, efficient and secure transaction.
Transaction management and forms software with all the must-have features, including current statewide contracts, local forms, and more.Transaction Products Service Providers Forms Libraries Support
Free advice to help you understand the form you're using with Forms Tutor® and identify which form you need for your transaction with Forms Advisor™
C.A.R. Standard Forms are developed by the C.A.R. Legal Department which gathers input from real estate professionals and attorneys to create user-friendly, comprehensive, and dependable forms.
C.A.R. now offers a list of Certified Home Inspectors for our REALTORS® members. Participants of this program have completed certain background and education requirements. Click Here to see the program details and a directory of Certified Home Inspectors.
Advice, Support and materials to improve your transactions.
We're here to help, people! Business products and tools to empower REALTORS®.
Your one-stop-source for real estate products, forms, education, high-tech tools and more
Everything you need for a successful property management & leasing business
A collection of educational and technology resources designed to help you achieve profitability and better prepare for your financial present and future.
Download the latest C.A.R. mobile apps, including CARmojis & Stickers, C.A.R., Legal Hotline, CA REALTOR® EXPO, and zipForm Mobile.
Q: Where do I go to get legal questions answered? A: Easy, look to the right!
This is a resource page for all things RPA 2021. It includes links to the RPA and RPA-related forms, training, legal presentations, and publications.
Legal articles, many in question and answer format, are currently available on over 150 subjects in 50-plus categories.
Need help on a legal issue? First, pick one of the topics.
Quick Guides (1-page articles), PowerPoint presentations, and videos on key legal topics.
Wish you could catch up on California real estate law without having to read even more documents? Relax and watch a video as C.A.R.’s Legal Live Webinars bring you up-to-date on the hottest topics in real estate law.
While you’re driving to your next meeting, would like our attorneys to update you on how to best protect yourself and your clients? Subscribe to our Legal Matters Podcast, and we’ll bring the most critical information right to your device.
Help, I need backup! Whether it's legal or financial help you need, C.A.R.'s got your back with these resources.
If you're a member looking to resolve a minor dispute or communication issue with another REALTOR®, a C.A.R. ombudsman may be able to help!
C.A.R. REALTOR® volunteers are specifically trained and are available to answer questions from other members about the Code of Ethics, and can provide information and limited counseling concerning its proper interpretation.
Your lifeline to the lending community formerly known as the Finance Helpline and Mortgage Rescue™. Find contacts and answers to all mortgage related questions, and problems that arise in your real estate transaction. Get assistance today!Lending Resources
Looking for additional assistance? The Customer Contact Center is looking forward to serving you Monday through Friday between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4:45 p.m.
The C.A.R. Real Estate Mediation Center for Consumers has mediators available to assist buyers and sellers (as well as other parties to real estate transactions) in resolving their disputes.
Did you know that for zero dollars and zero cents, you can speak with an attorney about your transaction? If you don't believe us, check it out yourself.
We offer a wide array of real estate educational courses, certifications & designations in various formats.
Easily renew your real estate license with the FREE 45 hour online license renewal package from C.A.R.
Distinguish yourself by learning how to build a business that specializes in niche markets to nearly double your earning potential in various real estate sectors
Browse our class schedule to find when and where to take real estate courses.Course Catalog Online Bundles Risk and Education Management System Annual Education Experience
Prepare to earn your real estate license with our online courses
Complete your eight-hour NMLS license renewal requirement through our NMLS-approved provider, OnlineEd
Mark your calendars for our yearly meetings and events!
The main Business Meetings page includes important links for Directors and Committee Members.Tentative Program Meeting Registration
NAR meeting information and materials.
You're the brand! Use our marketing tools to tell your story.
A one-stop shop for tools and and resources to educate consumers about the intricacies of buying and selling a home and how a REALTOR® can help.Prop 19 Down Payment Resource Directory Infographics One Cool Thing Tax Reform One Sheets Fire Insurance One Sheet
Explore and interact with the latest market statistics.Housing Market Summary County Market Updates Housing Perspective Market @ A Glance
Marketing tools from C.A.R.'s consumer advertising campaign
Got knowledge? All the info you need on California’s housing market, economy, and issues impacting the industry.
This information is designed for Real Estate Brokers and Office Managers to assist you in supporting your real estate business.
CCRE's mission is to advance industry knowledge and innovation with an emphasis on convening key experts and influence-makers.
Frequently Asked Questions about the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
Be trendy -- stay current with our latest market forecasts and data analyses.
The latest housing market forecast and projection to what lays ahead.
View the latest sales and price numbers. Find out where sales will be in upcoming months.Current Sales & Price Statistics
Your housing hub for market analysis, economic trends, and housing news.
Get a roundup of weekly economic and market news that matters to real estate and your business.
Gain insights through interactive dashboards and downloadable content.Shareable Reports Interactive Dashboards
Catch up with the latest outreaches and webinars by the Research and Economics team.
C.A.R. conducts survey research with members and consumers on a regular basis to get a better understanding of the housing market and the real estate industry. Results and analyses from these studies are released in different formats – written report, power-point, infographic, webinar, and podcast - and can be found in this section.
You’ve gone pro! So here are guidelines about MLS rules and professional standards.
California Model MLS Rules, Issues Briefing Papers, and other articles and materials related to MLS policy.Statewide MLS Initiative
Looking for information on how to file an interboard arbitration complaint? You've come to the right place! Find the rules, timeline and filing documents here.
Summaries and photos of California REALTORS® who violated the Code of Ethics and were disciplined with a fine, letter of reprimand, suspension, or expulsion.
The most recent edition of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice of the National Association of REALTORS®.
The California Professional Standards Reference Manual, Local Association Forms, NAR materials and other materials related to Code of Ethics enforcement and arbitration.Resources for Hearings via Zoom Online Training for Professional Standards Volunteers Professional Standards Webinars Professional Standards Ambassador Program Professional Standards Administrator Certification Professional Standards Train the Trainer
An industry that works together, thrives together. Participate in legislative advocacy as a C.A.R. member!
C.A.R. advocates for REALTOR® issues in Washington D.C., Sacramento and in city and county governments throughout California.
CREPAC, LCRC, IMPAC, ALF and the RAF comprise C.A.R.'s political fundraising arm.REALTOR® Action Fund
Learn how you can make a difference, by getting involved yourself or by passing along valuable information to your clients.
It's the Law -- C.A.R.'s legal eagles tell you what you need to know to stay out of trouble.
California Code of Ethics and Arbitration Rules and external link to JAMS Arbitration service.
Learn on-the-go! The Legal Matters Podcast gives you bite-size nuggets of power-packed legal information that will help you protect yourself and your clients. Join our attorneys for a “Legal Bedtime Story” or for the scoop on vital issues like the “Top 5 RPA Mistakes”.
Represent! Join C.A.R. in our community and foundation programs.
Californians for Homeownership was founded in response to the California Legislature’s call for public interest organizations to fight local anti-housing policies on behalf of the millions of California residents who need access to more affordable housing.
Programs and grants to provide direct assistance to address the housing crisis in California.Make A Donation
The Rising Star Award program is a C.A.R. initiative designed to work with the brokerage community to recognize their up-and-coming agents.
C.A.R. stands ready to assist REALTORS® who have been impacted by wildfires through its Disaster Relief Fund and NAR's REALTORS® Relief Foundation.California Wildfire Resources
Scholarships for California students planning to pursue a career in real estate.
Grants for California REALTORS® and residents pursuing real estate education.
Find out more information on key diversity and inclusion programs and projects available.Fair Housing Latino Professionals Network C.A.R. Women's Initiative
New to the industry? YPN is a network to sharpen your skills, heighten your leadership, and connect with fellow REALTORS®.
Adding REALTOR® next to your name is cool. What comes with that title is even cooler. Check out your benefits.
As a member of C.A.R., you receive more than 100 free and discounted benefits. Find out more about your member benefits here.C.A.R. Member Discounts NAR Member Discounts C.A.R. Insurance Products
As a C.A.R. member you may have questions about your association and the industry. Find the answers here.Member FAQs Glossary Service Providers
This is so us...who we are and what we do.
C.A.R. is a statewide trade association dedicated to the advancement of professionalism in real estate.Annual Report
Meet the 2023 C.A.R. Leadership Team
C.A.R.'s Media Center houses the Association's news releases, media guidelines, and logos.News Releases
Looking for additional assistance? The Customer Contact Center is looking forward to serving you Monday through Friday between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4:45 p.m.
Whichever department you are looking to speak with, don't hesitate to reach out! We'd love to hear from you.
Member Legal Services
Tel (213) 739-8282
Fax (213) 480-7724
November 20, 2018 (revised)
Table of Contents
|I.||Independent Contractor Relationship Confirmed|
|II.||Agency Form Changes (C.A.R. form AD "Disclosure Regarding Real Estate Agency Relationships")|
|III.||Changes to the Agency Confirmation|
|IV.||Delivery of Copy of Listing|
|V.||Delivery of the TDS, NHD Statement, the agent's visual inspection, and the Buyer's Cancellation Rights|
|VI.||TDS Exemptions and Trust Sales|
|VII.||Licenses and Notifications|
|X.||Clarification and Confirmation of Existing Law|
The C.A.R. sponsored “clean-up” legislation, signed by the Governor on September 29, 2018, updates many of the laws affecting agents and brokers. Among other changes, the clean-up law conforms the Real Estate Law to existing practice. It also eliminates antiquated or confusing laws, clarifies and reiterates existing law, and introduces plain language where appropriate.
The Clean-Up law was written in two bills, Assembly Bill 1289 and Assembly Bill 2884. Together they effect changes to the Civil Code and the Business and Professions Code. All of the changes in the clean-up law become effective on January 1, 2019.
I. Independent Contractor Relationship Confirmed
Q1. How does the Clean-up law reiterate and confirm the independent contractor status of salespersons and broker-associates?
A1. The Real Estate Law has for decades recognized that brokers and agents may choose to contract between themselves as either independent contractors or as employers and employees (B&P Code Section 10032). The clean-up law reiterates and confirms this right in three ways:
1. The words “employment,” and “employer” have been removed from the Real Estate Law. These words had been previously used in a generic sense to connote any business relationship between a broker and salesperson of either employment or independent contractor status.
2. The clean-up law substitutes the words “retain” and “retention” in place of prior references to “employment” “employers” and “employ.” Furthermore, the term "employing broker" has been replaced by "responsible broker." “Retain” and “retention” are defined to refer to the relationship between a responsible broker and licensee, which can be one of either independent contractor or employee.
3. Finally, the clean-up law clarifies that the broker has a duty to supervise salespersons and broker-associates regardless of employee or independent contractor status (B&P Code Section 10010.5(b)(1)). This effectively eliminates the “control” argument against independent contractor status. The current legal argument against categorizing an agent as an independent contractor is that since a broker has de jure supervisory control over an agent, that agent is necessarily an employee. This argument is based on case law stating that a worker is an employee when the principal has “control” over the work performed. The clean-up law addresses and dispatches this argument by stating that the relationship between a broker and agent may be one of independent contractor regardless of the broker’s duty to supervise and oversee the licensed acts of their agents.
II. Agency Form Changes (C.A.R. form AD “Disclosure Regarding Real Estate Agency Relationships")
Q2. Has the “third” agency form been eliminated in the clean-up law?
A2. Yes. The “third” agency form has been eliminated. Since the inception of the agency disclosure law in the 80’s, a non-dual agent for the buyer has had to provide an additional agency form with the offer to purchase for the seller to sign and return. That made sense in the 80’s when the “selling agent” (whom we would now refer to as a buyer’s agent) would typically represent the seller in a sub-agency relationship.
But that ship has long sailed. Today, the “selling agent” almost never represents the seller (with the exception of a dual agency). So, the delivery of the third agency form in a non-dual agency transaction just makes no sense. Thus, the new law has eliminated the obligation.
Q3. Will the agency form still use the phrase “selling agent” to refer to the buyer’s agent?
A3. No. Along with the third agency form, the phrase “selling agency” has been eliminated. Now this agent will be simply be called the “buyer’s agent.” This is just common sense. The change comports with existing practice and uses plain English in place of industry jargon.
The plain English changes on the agency and confirmation forms are as follows:
Q4. How does the clean-up law affect the handling of “confidential information” in a dual agency?
A4. Previously, the agency form gave little guidance on the handling of confidential information in a dual agency. It merely stated that a dual agent may not, without express consent, disclose to the other party that the seller would accept a price less than the listing price or that the Buyer would pay a price greater than the price offered. In many circumstances an agent was left with a difficult choice of breaching their fiduciary duty to the seller if they disclosed seemingly confidential information or breaching their fiduciary duty to their buyer if they didn’t (or visa-versa).
The new agency form adds that the agent will not disclose, without the express consent of the principal, confidential information including facts related to either the buyer’s or seller’s
This, in addition to the previous language concerning price disclosures, will allow dual agents to maintain confidences in appropriate circumstances with the assurance that they are acting within the law.
Q5. How does the clean-up law re-emphasize that the buyer has a duty to exercise reasonable care to protect themselves?
A5. The agency form has new language which reiterates existing law regarding the buyer’s obligation to act reasonably and take basic precautions to learn the facts regarding the property he or she intends to purchase. It states:
Q6. Is the agency form required even on a residential 5+ properties?
A6. Yes. Previously there was an exemption for 5+ multi-unit residential properties (that were not vacation rentals). This exemption has been eliminated, and the agency form is required for all properties including 5+ residential properties. Moreover, the law now clearly indicates that the agency is required on vacant land, mobile homes and ground leases coupled with improvements.
III. Changes to the Agency Confirmation
Q7. How has the agency confirmation been changed?
A7. The most significant change is that under the clean-up law, both brokers and agents are identified. Previously, only brokers were identified. The new form will appear as follows:
In the above form the changes include:
Q8. I am a listing agent and our brokerage is representing both the buyer and seller. But I do not consider myself as a “dual agent.” Am I still to check the box indicating “dual agent?”
A8. Yes. Even though you do not consider yourself as representing the buyer, you are in fact part of a dual agency. On the confirmation form, it should therefore indicate “dual agent” in the box under your name.
IV. Delivery of Copy of Listing
Q9. How has the clean-up law changed the rules regarding delivery of a copy of the listing agreement?
A9. Under the clean-up law, a copy of the listing must be provided to the seller “as soon as practicable” after the listing is signed. Moreover, a copy of the listing may be delivered electronically where the parties have agreed to conduct the transaction by electronic means.
Previously, the law required that a copy of the listing agreement had to be provided to the seller “at the time the signature was obtained.” This requirement made sense when forms were typically filled out in duplicate on carbon paper and signatures were obtained in person. Nowadays, this requirement can be a practical impossibility, putting the agent in technical breach of the legal requirements.
Be Cognizant of the Code of Ethics! Even though the law has changed regarding delivery of a listing agreement, the Code of Ethics has not. Under Article 9 of the 2019 Code of Ethics & Standards of Practice, “A copy of each agreement shall be furnished to each party to such agreements upon their signing or initialing.” This ethics requirement would of course encompass listing agreements.
Where the Code of Ethics sets a stricter standard than what would otherwise be legally required, as a REALTOR®, you are bound to follow the Code of Ethics.
V. Delivery of the TDS, NHD Statement, the agent’s visual inspection, and the Buyer’s Cancellation Rights
Q10. Under the clean-up law, how may the TDS, NHD Statement (The Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement) and the agent’s visual inspection be delivered?
A10. The clean-up law allows delivery of these documents by electronic means where the parties have agreed to conduct the transaction by electronic means.
Previously, the law allowed only that these documents would be personally delivered or sent by mail. This reflected the methods of delivery during the 80’s when the law first came into force but does not reflect the practical reality of how transactions are conducted today.
Q11. How has the right of the buyer to cancel been clarified by the clean-up law?
A11. Under existing law, a buyer has a right to cancel a purchase agreement at any time prior to delivery of the TDS, or within 3 days after it is personally delivered or within 5 days after it is delivered by mail. This law has been updated as follows:
Practice Tip: Although the law contains a cancellation right based upon delivery of the TDS, this cancellation is seldom relied upon by buyers in cancelling a purchase agreement. Instead in the vast majority of transactions where a buyer wishes to cancel, they will rely upon the various contingency rights to cancel. The standard contingencies in C.A.R. purchase agreements include contingency for loan, appraisal, disclosures, investigations and title. Only in relatively unusual circumstances will a buyer attempt to cancel based upon delivery of the TDS.
VI. TDS Exemptions and Trust Sales
Q12. How has the TDS exemption for trust sales been changed?
A12. The TDS exemption for trust sales no longer allows co-trustees of a revocable trust to claim the exemption. The existing law generally grants the exemption to the successor trustee of an irrevocable trust (typically, after the trustee has passed away), and generally disallows the exemption to a trustee of a revocable when that person set up the trust (and typically is still alive). But inexplicably, it grants a further exemption for co-trustees of a revocable trust simply on the basis that there is more than one trustee.
The new law aligns the exemption with common sense. When the trustor or trustors (typically the person or persons who have set the trust up) are in fact the existing trustee(s), they are not eligible for the exemption and must complete and deliver a TDS. This is the case even when there are co-trustees.
To be clear, the exemption is fairly technical. The exact language of the new exemption is as follows: “This exemption shall not apply to a if the trustee is a natural person who is a trustee of a revocable trust and he or she is a former owner of the property or an occupant in possession of the property within the preceding year.” Some people interpret this language to mean that any person who has lived on the property within the preceding year is ineligible for the exemption. That is not what this means. A trustee of an irrevocable trust is still entitled to the exemption regardless of whether they have lived on the property. Mind you, they still have to disclose material facts affecting value of desirability. They just need not complete a TDS.
VII. Licenses and Notifications
Q13. Is the responsible broker still required to maintain physical possession of a salesperson’s license?
A13. No. Under the clean-up law, the requirement that the responsible broker maintain physical possession of a salesperson’s license has been eliminated.
Q14. Is the salesperson required to mark out the name of their old broker on their license and write in the name of their new one when they change brokerages?
A14. No. this requirement has been eliminated.
Q15. Is a licensee required to mark out their current business address and write in their new one when they change brokerages?
A15. No. This requirement has been eliminated.
Q16. How has the clean-up law changed regarding a broker’s duty to notify the DRE of changes to a salesperson or broker-associate status?
A16. The clean-up law gives greater discretion to the DRE to specify how notification will be provided whenever a salesperson or broker-associate is terminated or retained.
Presently, under existing law, when a salesperson or broker associate is terminated or retained, the responsible broker must notify the DRE “immediately” and “in writing.” Under the clean-up law notification by the broker will be “in a manner specified by the commissioner.”
This change will likely have no immediate impact since a broker may presently notify the DRE of the retention or termination of a salesperson using the eLicensing system. And the DRE is presently in the process of adding broker associate affiliations to the eLicensing system. (As of right now, broker-associate retentions or terminations must be sent in by person or by mail using the DRE form RE 215). However, in the future the clean-up law will allow the DRE to change as technology changes without concern that it lacks legal authority.
Q17. Under the clean-up law, how are licensees (whether salespersons, broker-associates or brokers) to notify the DRE of changes to their business addresses?
A17. The cleanup law gives greater discretion to the DRE to decide the “manner of notification.”
Presently, licensees can change mailing and main office addresses on the eLicensing system, as well as update valid contact information such as phone numbers and email addresses. However, the DRE does not permit brokers to cancel a main office address and place their license in a “no business address” status using eLicensing. They would need to submit form RE 204 in order to complete that type of change. The clean-up law does not change that.
Salespersons can make changes of sponsoring brokers on eLicensing. The effective date of the change is the date of the new responsible broker certifies the request through elicensing. The elicensing system may also be used by a sales agent to change their status to "no broker affiliation."
VIII. Corporate brokerages
Q18. How does the clean-up law allow a corporate brokerage to continue to conduct licensed activity in the event of death or incapacity of the designated broker?
A18. It will allow a new designated officer to continue operations as long as an application is filed within 10 days.
Presently, the law requires a corporate brokerage to act through a designated licensee at all times (Regulations of the Real Estate Commissioner 2740). The law contains no allowance for the continued functioning of the brokerage even in the event of death or incapacity of the designated broker. The practical result is that many corporate brokers will operate in technical breach of the licensing rules.
Under the clean-up law, a corporate brokerage may continue to operate as a licensee without interruption under its existing license as long as an application for a new designated officer is filed with the DRE within 10 days.
Q19. Can a designated broker of a corporation continue to act as the designated broker even if they let their individual broker’s license lapse?
A19. Yes. The clean-up law clarifies the existing rule that a designated broker may work though a corporate brokerage without maintaining their individual broker’s license as long as they are qualified to obtain a broker’s license. That is, the designated broker must have either passed the broker license examination and be qualified to obtain a broker license or be currently licensed as a real estate broker. An officer of a corporation through whom it is licensed to act need not maintain an individual broker’s license but is otherwise subject to all duties and responsibilities of a licensed broker.
IX. Other Issues
The clean-up legislation has clarified existing law across a range of issues both large and small. Here is a list of other changes within the clean-up legislation:
X. Clarification and Confirmation of Existing Law
Q20. Was the clean-up legislation intended to change the law?
A20. No. The clean-up legislation is not intended to create new law, but merely clarify and confirm what the laws always were intended to be. Indeed, the clean-up law states explicitly that it is not intended to affect any of the following:
Q21. Where can I get additional legal information?
A21. This legal article is just one of the many legal publications and services offered by C.A.R. to its members. For a complete listing of C.A.R.'s legal products and services, please visit car.org/legal .
Readers who require specific advice should consult an attorney. C.A.R. members requiring legal assistance may contact C.A.R.'s Member Legal Hotline at (213) 739-8282, Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Saturday, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. C.A.R. members who are broker-owners, office managers, or Designated REALTORS® may contact the Member Legal Hotline at (213) 739-8350 to receive expedited service. Members may also submit online requests to speak with an attorney on the Member Legal Hotline by going to http://www.car.org/legal/legal-hotline-access/ . Written correspondence should be addressed to:
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS®
Member Legal Services
525 South Virgil Avenue
Los Angeles, CA 90020
The information contained herein is accurate as of November 20, 2018. It is intended to provide general answers to general questions and is not intended as a substitute for individual legal advice. Advice in specific situations may differ depending upon a wide variety of factors. Therefore, readers with specific legal questions should seek the advice of an attorney. Written and revised by Robert Bloom, Esq.
Copyright© 2018 CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® (C.A.R.). Permission is granted to C.A.R. members to reprint this material in hardcopy or PDF format only for personal use or with individual clients. This material may not be used or reproduced for commercial purposes. Other reproduction or use is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of the C.A.R Legal Department. All rights reserved.