×
Your C.A.R.
Industry 360°
Transaction Center
Learn & Thrive

C.A.R. Board of Directors and Committees

The main Business Meetings page includes important links for Directors and Committee Members.

Current Meeting Materials Tentative Program Committee Selection Summary of Action Items Meeting Registration
REALTOR® EXPO

CALIFORNIA REALTOR® EXPO, the state's largest real estate trade show.


NAR Meetings

NAR meeting information and materials.


C.A.R. Women's Initiative

On June 8th C.A.R. held its inaugural WomanUP!™ conference in Pasadena, California. Over 300 women and men were present for a one-day of professional development devoted to giving powerful women bold tools to take their career to the next level.


License Renewal

Easily renew your real estate license with the FREE 45 hour online license renewal package from C.A.R.


Pre-License Training

Prepare to earn your real estate license with our online courses


Career Path

Build and drive success for your real estate business with the training you need for continuous improvement


Designations / Certifications

Distinguish yourself by learning how to build a business that specializes in niche markets to nearly double your earning potential in various real estate sectors


Education Calendar

Browse our class schedule to find when and where to take real estate courses.


Course Catalog

Get the description you need to learn more about our many courses offered.  To find courses by career path, please visit our Career Path page.


NMLS/MLO CE Courses

Complete your eight-hour NMLS license renewal requirement through our NMLS-approved provider, OnlineEd


Thought Leadership

This program represents our ongoing commitment to enhancing the professionalism of all our members.


Speeches & Presentations

Speeches & Presentations from C.A.R. Business Meetings and other Events


Multimedia Library

From webinars to videos and podcasts to blogs, C.A.R. keeps you in the know.

Housing Matters Blog Slideshows Videos
Publications

C.A.R. publishes eight magazine issues and various newsletters throughout the year.

Newsletters California Real Estate Magazine
Webinars

Webinars focusing on the critical issues that impact REALTORS®, their clients, and the real estate industry.

California Housing Market Webinars Finance Helpline Webinars Legal Webinars Upcoming Webinars
For Your Clients

A one-stop shop for tools and and resources to educate consumers about the intricacies of buying and selling a home and how a REALTOR® can help.

ClientDIRECT® Infographics
Charts & Graphs

Explore and interact with the latest market statistics.

County Market Updates Market @ A Glance Market Snapshot
Digital Tools

Marketing tools from C.A.R.'s consumer advertising campaign

CARmojis Legal Hotline App REALTOR® RealTalk REALTOR® ReelMaker
Social Media Content

See the latest social media content from C.A.R. and find content for you to share on your own social media.

Featured Share of the Week Success with Social Media
Top Searches
CLOSE

Disclosure exemptions in sales of REO properties

Email Article
Lock icon
The page you are sharing is not public and requires a car.org account to view.
Send Email
What is this?
Add a quick link to this page from the Homepage when you are signed in
Share Article

November 15, 2012

Transactions and Regulatory Committee [lead committee]
Legislative Committee

Question Presented: Should C.A.R. sponsor legislation to repeal the exemption from the TDS for REO properties, and thereby force foreclosing lenders complete a TDS?

Action Necessary: No - Optional

Position to be Taken [select one]:
1. Do Nothing. Maintain existing law.
2. Sponsor legislation to require REO sellers to provide a completed TDS (Transfer Disclosure Statement) in connection with a sale.
3. Other:

Direction to C.A.R. Staff:

Discussion:Caveat emptor ("let the buyer beware") is not the rule in California real estate, if indeed it ever was. The landmark case of Easton vs. Strassburger made it explicit as far back as the mid-1980s that both sellers and their agents could not sidestep the duty of disclosing what should be known about the property in the transaction.

C.A.R. sponsored legislation that clarified (and thus limited) the liability exposure of sellers and agents by codifying the duty and a statutory form for compliance in Civil Code Section 1102 and following.  Agents duties, and a standard of care, were similarly codified in Section 2079 and following of the same code. A 1993 case, Loughrin v. Superior Court made it clear that one could not escape disclosure liability simply by characterizing a sale as "as is."  C.A.R. legislation responded to that trap for unwary sellers and agents by requiring the Transfer Disclosure Statement (TDS) to be used in "as is" sales too. 

Some existing disclosure statutes, including the TDS statute, exempt foreclosing lenders from the requirement for completed statutory form disclosures; however, lenders are bound by the same obligation as any other seller to disclose material facts in their possession.  Some Realtors® have reported an unwillingness of lenders to make any disclosures and insist on an "as is" transaction that does not include formal disclosures.

Existing Exemptions. Civil Code 1102.2 contains a lengthy list of transfers that are not required to utilize a TDS.  One of these exempt classes of transactions (CC 1102.2(c) is for foreclosing lenders.  As a result, an REO sale by a lender is not subject to the CC1102 Article, and a TDS need not accompany the sale.

Note too; the legislative intent of Section 1102.2 is not intended to affect the existing duty to disclose in transactions not covered by the statute. In other words, they are exempt from the TDS, but not from disclosure obligations. Anecdotal reports suggest that lenders' asset managers are unaware of this obligation to "tell what you know."

What do lenders "know" now?  Even though a foreclosing lender may not have been living in the property, it may possess a considerable amount of information.  For example, a relatively recent appraisal may still be part of the bank’s file; or, there may have been a home inspection report generated as part of an asset manager’s activities. There may have been a citation for code violations to which the new owner (former lender) has responded, or there may have been inspections and reports generated from prior negotiations in connection with a transaction that did not close. 

Requiring a TDS on REO properties. The TDS can only be completed based upon a physical inspection of the property, and requires information from both the agent and the seller. If the lender is to complete such a disclosure, unless it already has an inspection report, it will have to inspect the property. Would a mandate to complete a TDS accomplish better information disclosure, or just increase the cost of the transaction?

What position will the lenders take? On the natural, lenders would be inclined to oppose any new mandate or new cost. However, if the requirement was limited to specified items already in a lender's file (for example a recent pest report or current inspection report), the burden would be relatively slight, especially if the lender is allowed to bill the requesting buyer for recovery of its costs of making the reports available. Cost recovery is currently the rule for making appraisals available. However, other sellers are not entitled to bill a recipient for the cost of supplying statutory disclosures.  If the lender were also given a statutory safe harbor from additional disclosures if they transmit the information in good faith, it might also create an incentive to comply without a mandate.

Should C.A.R. sponsor legislation requiring lenders to make the disclosures described?

This material is for discussion purposes only and has not been approved by the Transactions and Regulatory, Legislative or Executive Committees or the Board of Directors]


FEEDBACK